Newswatch figures show fewer than one in 1,000 contributors to Today’s EU coverage were supporters of withdrawal from the Labour party or the British left.
BBC Director General Lord Hall told the House of Commons select media committee in a
hearing in October that the Corporation was determined to deliver impartiality by ensuring
that a range of voices on key issues was heard.
Newswatch’s latest figures – based on monitoring approximately half of the Today editions
since 2005 – show the programme has carried interviews and soundbite contributions
from only three left-wing advocates of withdrawal. The statistics show that there were
3,513 contributions to the various EU discussions on Today in nine years, but that
withdrawalists from the Labour Party and British left represented just 0.09% of guests, or
one in every 1,171 EU-related appearances.
The three speakers who contributed to the EU debate were Labour MP Austin Mitchell in
September 2009, Labour MP Gisela Stuart in October 2012, and Labour Party donor John
Mills in June 2013. Their combined contributions amounted to approximately 5 minutes
of airtime, but only 1 minute featured the speakers actually making any sort of case for
Newswatch surveys: Since 2005, Today has carried only six minutes a year of those who support EU withdrawal talking about the subject
Latest Newswatch report: Today ignored UK Withdrawal from the EU, but gave multiple airings for those who want stronger EU ties.
The latest News-watch report shows that Today went out of its way to give those who were opposed to change in Britain’s relationship with the EU – including Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg – multiple platforms in which they had clear time and space to advance arguments in favour of their views, including the hotly disputed claim by Europhiles that 3.5m jobs would be lost if the relationship with the EU was fundamentally changed. This assertion went unchallenged by the Today presenter.
Is the BBC properly balanced and impartial in its reporting of complex issues such as the EU, immigration and climate change?
- BrexitCentral podcast: In conversation with Lord Lawson of Blaby 26th April 2017 Darren Grimes
- Sir Keir Starmer’s speech leaves a number of unanswered questions about Labour’s Brexit policy 25th April 2017 Hugh Bennett
- What the Conservative manifesto needs to say about Brexit 24th April 2017 James Cleverly MP
- Can UKIP remain a credible force if their leader doesn’t fight a parliamentary seat? 24th April 2017 David Scullion
- Labour needs to select Brexit candidates to win 23rd April 2017 Brendan Chilton
- Remainers are the ones truly obsessed with nostalgia 22nd April 2017 Will Saunders
Popular Posts and Pages
- This election is a battle between the Tories and the broadcasters
- About News-Watch
- Nick Robinson wheels out usual BBC defences against EU coverage bias claims
- Nick Booth: The BBC is a candidate for a bonfire of the insanities
- Monitoring Projects and Reports
- BBC Trust defends Corporation’s Harlow ‘race hate’ sensationalism
- Today Programme - Post-Referendum Business News Survey, March 2017
- BBC Bias - A Progress Report